Most people think recovery is about getting back to normal.
In oncology, I’ve learned something far more uncomfortable:
The old “normal” is gone — and trying to restore it, is what causes the real suffering.
The Body You Remember, The Life You Lost and the One You Have to Build
Every week in my clinical practice I see the same pattern: patients who have survived cancer, completed treatment, undergone reconstruction — and are still devastated with the result.
Not because the surgery failed.
Not because the outcome is poor.
But because they are grieving a version of themselves that no longer exists.
For years I assumed this was a communication problem. Then an expectation management problem.
Now I see it as identity grief.
And it shows up far beyond medicine — in burnout, divorce, career collapse, aging, and every major rupture that separates the self we remember from the self we own now.
The Case That Made the Pattern Impossible to Ignore
Recently a patient came to me after years of reconstructive procedures: failed implants, expansions, complex reconstruction, multiple revisions.
From a technical point of view, the final result was good.
But she was devastated.
Not only because of the complications.
But because the reconstructed breast did not match the internal breast memory she had carried — a sensory imprint of a body of a time before her illness.
She asked me:
“What can you do to give me my breast back?”
“Will I ever be like before?”
“When will I feel normal again?”
These are not surgical questions.
They are grief questions.
What she truly meant was:
“Who am I now, that the old version of me is gone?”
No operation — no matter how skillful — can answer that. No operation can solve that.
A Lesson From Early in My Career
As a junior doctor on a burn ward, I witnessed a moment I didn’t understand at the time.
A young woman survived a severe car fire and lost one leg below her knee. When she woke up, she was terrified and disoriented. She demanded to see a senior attending.
He was a former navy officer. Direct, uncompromising. A die-hard christian.
He walked in and said:
“You have lost the idol that was your body.
The body you remember is gone.
Your life is not over — but that version of you is.”
She screamed. She broke. Everyone in the room thought he had gone too far. I thought to myself “You can’t say something like that at this moment.” Apparently you can.
Months later she thanked him.
Because he named the truth she was coming to fight long before she could face it.
He ended the bargaining — the mental loop where the mind tries to reverse time instead of moving forward.
I have never forgotten that moment.
And I see the same mechanism in breast reconstruction, in high performers after burnout, in founders after collapse, in anyone whose old identity is no longer accessible.
The Expert Wisdom Triad
There’s an old surgical triad:
The good surgeon knows how to operate.
The better surgeon knows when to operate.
The wise surgeon knows when not to operate.
I used to think this was about anatomy and risk.
Now I understand it’s also about identity.
Operating on someone who is still psychologically anchored to their pre-cancer self — still worshipping the idol of their former body — is not surgery.
It is enabling a fantasy that the past can be restored.
And that guarantees dissatisfaction, revision spirals, repeated disappointment, sometimes even conflict.
This is because the psychological contract is impossible.
Now most patients after cancer adapt quickly. But not all do, and identifying these, is important. For them, as much as for ourselves.
The same applies outside medicine:
• Trying to “save” a relationship that has already ended
• Forcing a return to a pace of life that burned you out
• Attempting to reclaim youth instead of aging into a new identity
Sometimes the wisest intervention is naming what is already gone. And then re-construct from there.
The Restoration Fallacy
After any major rupture — cancer, trauma, burnout, divorce, status loss — the mind gravitates to the same trap:
The belief that the old self can be restored.
That you just need the right intervention, the right recovery protocol, the right timeline — and you’ll be “back.”
But the old baseline is gone.
This is the Restoration Fallacy — the mistaken belief that wholeness comes from reclaiming what was lost.
It doesn’t.
It never has.
The Reconstruction Path
There is only one path that leads to real stability:
Building the next self — not resurrecting the old one.
Forward, not backward.
New, not restored.
This is the line I use with patients and anyone facing irreversible change:
“You cannot rebuild the old self. You can only build the next self.”
Instead of resignation it is more an alignment with reality and the foundation of actual healing.
Why High Performers Struggle Most
There are many groups other than cancer patients that are especially vulnerable to the Restoration Fallacy.
High achievers are especially vulnerable to the Restoration Fallacy.
A burned-out executive tries to return to their old pace.
An athlete tries to reclaim their old body.
A founder tries to recreate the confidence they had before collapse.
They’re not rebuilding, they are trying time-traveling.
Burnout, illness, loss, aging — these things don’t just change your performance abilities - they actually change your identity.
And identity cannot be restored.
The Tool We’re Building
In my department, we are beginning piloting a brief clinic-based screener to detect when a patient is still anchored to their pre-cancer body identity — still trapped in the Restoration Fallacy.
Because no amount of surgical excellence can help someone who is fighting the wrong battle.
Reconstruction only works when someone is ready to build forward, not reach backward.
And I suspect this applies far beyond oncology — to any domain where a former self has been lost.
The Real Work
You cannot return to the version of yourself that existed before a major rupture.
But you can build forward from there.
In surgery we do not reconstruct the past.
We assess what remains, accept what is missing, and build from there.
Identity works the same way.
Wholeness is not the restoration of the old self, it is probably more the construction of the next self, a new self where you can feel whole again.
The moment you stop bargaining with the old story, you can finally begin writing the new one.
In surgery as in other areas in life, the work is not really figuring out how to get back. But to decide what kind of future you can build from where you are at this moment.
To more from Life
Nicco
The Renaissance Protocol reflects on identity, performance, and building a life that integrates across domains.
Subscribe here or at therenaissanceprotocol.com
⸻
Restore that concept with sound in your mind:
